Independent agency · Portage & Michigan

Coverage that stays with the person who wrote it.

EverSafe is a local, independent insurance agency. We shop the market for auto, home, renters, life, and business insurance, then stay on the file when something actually happens.

IndependentAuto, home, life & business
LocalMichigan households & shops
DirectYou talk to the agent
Lines of business

The policies people actually call about.

Personal lines first, commercial for owners who want the same person on both the house and the shop, and life insurance for families who want it reviewed alongside everything else.

Father coaching his teenage son in the driver's seat

Auto

Liability, collision, comprehensive, and the Michigan pieces that still surprise people at renewal: PIP choices, uninsured motorist, and whether the car is titled to a person or a business.

Personal autoTeen driversMulti-carRideshare questions
Michigan auto insurance and PIP choices →

Umbrella

Extra liability over the auto and home when the underlying limits are no longer enough for the household.

Family walking together on a park path in the fall

Life

Term, permanent, and final expense coverage, explained plainly and matched to what the money needs to do for your family.

Life insurance →
Smiling baker behind a pastry display case

Small commercial

BOP-style packages, general liability, commercial auto, and landlord policies for owners who are tired of a 1-800 number. Contractors, shops, offices, and rental property, quoted after a real look at the operations, not a three-question form.

General liabilityBusiness propertyCommercial autoLessors risk
Business insurance: BOP, liability, workers comp →
The quote

Three steps. No portal maze.

Send the basics. We come back with options from the carriers we can actually place, in plain language, with the deductible and the exclusion called out.

01

Tell us what you need covered

Vehicles, address, household drivers, or a short description of the business. A current declarations page helps, if you have one.

02

We shop and compare

Independent means we are not locked to one company. You get the viable options, not a single take-it-or-leave-it number.

03

Bind, then keep the file here

Certificates, mortgagee changes, and claim calls come back to the same desk. Renewals are reviewed, not auto-piloted.

Why an independent agency

The carrier is the paper. The agency is the relationship.

More than one market

A direct writer can only sell what they have. We place with the carriers appointed to this agency and say so when a risk does not fit.

A decade in the work

Built by an agent with ten years in Michigan personal and commercial lines: quoting, servicing, and explaining the part of the policy people skip.

Service stays local

The point of an independent agency is that the person who wrote the account is still there at claim time and at renewal.

No invented savings

We will not promise a percentage off. Price follows the risk, the credits, and the carrier. The job is a fair comparison and a policy you can live with.

Our mission

Our mission is to put you, not an insurance company, at the center of every decision. We shop the market, explain your choices in plain language, and stay with you as your life and business grow.

Request a quote

Send the outline. We will call you back.

This request goes to the agency dashboard. Nothing is stored in the page itself. A request is not a binder.

Prefer the phone? Call (269) 256-4746.

Prefer texting? Check the text-message box on the form and we can send quote updates, renewal reminders, and service follow-ups by text.

SMS consent: By checking the text-message box on this form, I consent to receive account notifications and customer care text messages from Eversafe Insurance Michigan (Donn Carlisle Agency LLC) at the phone number provided. Message types: account notifications and customer care messages. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out at any time. Reply HELP for help. Consent is not a condition of purchase. The checkbox is optional and not checked by default. See our Privacy Policy and SMS Terms.

By submitting this form you agree that EverSafe Insurance may contact you by phone or email about your request. Text messages are sent only if you check the box above. We never sell or share your mobile number or text consent with third parties or affiliates for marketing purposes.

Coverage starts only when a carrier confirms it in writing.

Questions

Before you send the dec page.

Are you a carrier?

No. EverSafe is an independent agency. The insurance contract is with the company that issues the policy. We advise, place, and service.

Do you write the whole state?

Yes. Auto, home, renters, life, and small business insurance across Michigan. Some carriers restrict by county or class, and we will tell you if a risk is outside what we can place.

Can you beat my current premium?

Sometimes, not always. A lower price with a worse water exclusion is not a win. We compare limit, deductible, and form, then you choose.

What should I have ready?

Driver names and dates of birth, VIN or year/make/model, garaging address, and the current declarations page if you are rewriting an existing policy.

Privacy

Eversafe Insurance Michigan Privacy Summary

This privacy summary applies to Eversafe Insurance Michigan (Donn Carlisle Agency LLC). Read the full Privacy Policy.

Personal information we collect: your name, phone number, email address, ZIP code and mailing address, the coverage you are interested in, and details needed to quote insurance, such as drivers, vehicles, property and current policy information.

How we use personal information: to respond to your requests, prepare insurance quotes, place, service and renew policies, send account notifications and customer care messages, and keep records required by law.

Whether and with whom we share personal information: we share personal information only with the insurance companies we submit your request to and with service providers that help us run our agency, and when required by law. We do not sell your personal information. No mobile information will be shared with third parties or affiliates for marketing or promotional purposes. Text messaging opt-in data and consent will not be shared with or sold to any third party.